Top 10 Modern Baseball Cards to Buy Now (2025 Edition)

Updated for 2025 — While vintage cards hold historical prestige, the modern baseball market remains the most active and liquid in 2025. With high-end rookies, low-numbered parallels, and PSA 10 gems being traded daily, modern cards offer massive upside for both collectors and investors.

🥇 Top 10 Modern Baseball Cards to Buy in 2025

1. Elly De La Cruz – 2023 Topps Chrome Rookie Auto

One of the most electric players in the league. His autos are still underpriced relative to potential.

• Look for: Refractor /499, Gold /50, Orange /25 parallels
• PSA 10 price: ~$450 (base auto)

2. Gunnar Henderson – 2022 Bowman Chrome 1st Prospect Auto

AL Rookie of the Year and cornerstone of the Orioles. Future MVP buzz.

• Bowman Chrome 1st Autos are gold in this hobby
• PSA 10 price: ~$800 (base)

3. Julio Rodríguez – 2022 Topps Chrome Sapphire Rookie

A perennial All-Star already. High pop culture visibility + fan favorite = long-term value.

• Sapphire PSA 10: ~$375
• Look for image variations and numbered refractors

4. Corbin Carroll – 2023 Topps Chrome Update Auto

Blazing speed and breakout power. A 40/40 season in reach.

• Popular among west coast collectors
• PSA 10: ~$300 (base auto)

5. Shohei Ohtani – 2018 Topps Chrome Rookie Refractor

Now with the Dodgers and a dual-threat icon. His cards are blue-chip assets.

• PSA 10 Refractor: ~$1,500+
• Look for numbered colors, Gold /50 is ultra-premium

6. Jackson Holliday – 2022 Bowman Chrome Prospect Auto

Baseball’s #1 prospect. If he breaks into the majors this year, his cards will surge.

• PSA 10 base auto: ~$1,200
• A true "buy and hold" play

7. Mike Trout – 2011 Topps Update Rookie (PSA 10)

The safest modern baseball card investment of the last 10 years. Prices have dipped — a buying opportunity?

• PSA 10: ~$2,000–$2,500
• Always in demand

8. Anthony Volpe – 2023 Topps Finest Rookie Auto

Yankees shortstop with elite defense and improving bat.

• New York market boosts collectibility
• PSA 10: ~$275 (base auto)

9. Bobby Witt Jr. – 2022 Topps Chrome Rookie Auto

Solid across the board and just getting started. KC fans love him.

• PSA 10: ~$325
• Short prints and parallels are especially hot

10. Mookie Betts – 2014 Topps Update Rookie (PSA 10)

Already a two-time champion and MVP. Criminally undervalued compared to peers.

• PSA 10: ~$350
• Long-term lock for Cooperstown

🧠 What Makes a “Buy” in 2025?

• Low pop PSA 10s
• Performance + media exposure
• Parallel scarcity (Gold, Orange, Red)
• Market hype or hobby movement

🛒 Where to Buy Modern Baseball Cards

Tangiers Collectibles and Cards offers a curated selection of graded and raw modern baseball cards from today’s top stars and rising prospects.

👉 Shop Baseball Cards Now on eBay

🏁 Final Thoughts

Modern baseball cards offer a dynamic mix of passion and profit. Whether you're building your PC or flipping slabs, these ten cards are top-tier targets in 2025. Don’t wait for the next hot streak — invest in talent early and build your collection with purpose.